rec.puzzles Archive

What is the smallest number of coins that you can't make a dollar with?

combinatorics/coinage/impossible

Problem

What is the smallest number of coins that you can't make a dollar with?
I.e., for what N does there not exist a set of N coins adding up to a dollar?
It is possible to make a dollar with 1 current U.S. coin (a Susan B. Anthony),
2 coins (2 fifty cent pieces), 3 coins (2 quarters and a fifty cent piece),
etc.  It is not possible to make exactly a dollar with 101 coins.
Show solution
The answer is 77:

a) 5c  = 1 or 5;
b) 10c = 1 or 2 a's (1,2,6,10)
c) 25c = 1 or 2 b's + 1 a
d) 50c = 1 or 2 c's
e) $1  = 1 or 2 d's

total        penny        nickel        dime        quarter        half
5                1        2        1        1
6                3        1        1        1
7                5                1        1
8                4        3                1
9                6        2                1
10                8        1                1
11                10                        1
12                7        4        1
13                9        3        1
14                11        2        1
15                13        1        1
16                15                1
17                14        3
18                16        2
19                18        1
20                20
21        5        13        3
22        5        15        2
23        5        17        1
24        5        19
25        10        12        3
26        10        14        2
27        10        16        1
28        10        18
29        15        11        3
30        15        13        2
31        15        15        1
32        15        17
33        20        10        3
34        20        12        2
35        20        14        1
36        20        16
37        25        9        3
38        25        11        2
39        25        13        1
40        25        15
41        30        8        3
42        30        10        2
43        30        12        1
44        30        14
45        35        7        3
46        35        9        2
47        35        11        1
48        35        13
49        40        6        3
50        40        8        2
51        40        10        1
52        40        12
53        45        5        3
54        45        7        2
55        45        9        1
56        45        11
57        50        4        3
58        50        6        2
59        50        8        1
60        50        10
61        55        3        3
62        55        5        2
63        55        7        1
64        55        9
65        60        2        3
66        60        4        2
67        60        6        1
68        60        8
69        65        1        3
70        65        3        2
71        65        5        1
72        65        7
73        70                3
74        70        2        2
75        70        4        1
76        70        6
77        can't be done
78        75        1        2
79        75        3        1
80        75        5
81        can't be done
82        80                2
83        80        2        1
84        80        4        
85        can't be done
86        can't be done
87        85        1        1
88        85        3        
89        can't be done
90        can't be done
91        90                1
92        90        2
93-95        can't be done
96        95        1
97-99        can't be done
100        100