rec.puzzles Archive

One can fill the surface R^2 with triangles, squares and hexagons as shown below.

geometry/tiling/triangles.squares.hexagons New

New entry, edited from material collected for the archive and not yet in a released version.

Problem

One can fill the surface R^2 with triangles, squares and hexagons as
shown below.  What is the ratio between the 3, 4, and 6-gons if the
surface is filled with this pattern?

      ____              ____              ____              ____
   ,-'|  |`-.        ,-'|  |`-.        ,-'|  |`-.        ,-'|  |`-.
  /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\
 /   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \
|`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|
|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|
 \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /
  \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./
  /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\
 /   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \
|`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|
|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|
 \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /
  \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./
   `-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'\      /`-.|__|,-'
          \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /    \   \____/   /
           \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./      \,-'|  |`-./
            `-.|__|,-'        `-.|__|,-'        `-.|__|,-'

-- Mark van Hoeij <hoeij@sci.kun.nl>

[ Editor: van Hoeij's figure was PostScript ("shown in the postscript
  file included below" in the original); the ASCII drawing is Dan
  Hoey's, shortened here by one band. ]
Show solution
The easy way is to erase some of the lines, to form a monohedral tiling
by seashells.
      ____              ____              ____              ____
   ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.
  /          \      /          \      /          \      /          \
 /            \____/            \____/            \____/            \
 `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'
    \      /          \      /          \      /          \      /
     \____/            \____/            \____/            \____/
   ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.
  /          \      /          \      /          \      /          \
 /            \____/            \____/            \____/            \
 `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'|  |`-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'
    \      /          \      /`-.|__|,-'\      /          \      /
     \____/            \____/   /    \   \____/            \____/
   ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-./      \,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.
  /          \      /          \      /          \      /          \
 /            \____/            \____/            \____/            \
 `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'
    \      /          \      /          \      /          \      /
     \____/            \____/            \____/            \____/
   ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.
  /          \      /          \      /          \      /          \
 /            \____/            \____/            \____/            \
 `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'    `-.        ,-'
    \      /          \      /          \      /          \      /
     \____/            \____/            \____/            \____/

As the one in the center shows, each shell is composed of one hexagon,
two triangles, and three squares.

ObPuzzle: Is there a tiling in which every two congruent tiles are
equivalent, and which cannot be converted into a monohedral tiling?
By "equivalent", I mean that there is a symmetry of the tiling taking
one tile to the other.

-- Dan Hoey <Hoey@AIC.NRL.Navy.Mil>

[ Editor: so the ratio of triangles to squares to hexagons is 2:3:1.
  No answer to Hoey's ObPuzzle was found in the collected postings. ]