What bird comes from an egg, but doesn't lay eggs?
logic/simple.puzzles New
New entry, edited from material collected for the archive and not yet in a released version.
Problem
What bird comes from an egg, but doesn't lay eggs? (And other short
puzzles from two collections.)
[ Editor: the questions as quoted in the replies; the parenthetical in
the first line is the editor's. ]
Set 1 ("Simple Puzzles", 1993):
#1 What bird comes from an egg, but doesn't lay eggs? (7 letters)
#2 In a box you have 5 white socks and 7 brown ones. How many do you
have to pull out to have at least two white socks in your hand?
#3 There is 1 amoeba in jar #1, and two amoebas in jar #2. Two amoebas
take 3 hours to fill the whole jar, and amoeba duplicates each 3
minutes. How long will it take 1 amoeba to fill jar #1?
#4 One train goes from Moscow to Petersburg with speed of 80
kilometers/hour. Another train leaves Petersburg heading towards
Moscow with speed of 50 kilometers/hour. The distance between the two
cities is 700 kilometers. When the trains meet, which one will be
closer to Moscow?
#5 A ladder is hanging from a ship. 10 meters of ladder are above the
water. The tide covers 10 centimeters each hour. After 3 hours, how
much of the ladder will be above the water?
#6 A caterpillar is insane, so he climbs 3 meters up the tree each
day, and descends 1 meter down each night. If he starts on monday,
when will he reach the top of the tree, which is 8 meters above where
he is on monday?
#7 You have 1 glass of diet coke, and 1 glass of diet sprite. Each
glass is 100 grams. You take one spoon of coke, and pour it into the
glass with sprite. Then you take one spoon of the resulting liquid and
pour it back into the glass with coke. If 1 spoon contains 1 gram,
what percentage of coke will be in the sprite, and vice versa?
#8 You have two ideally insulated jars, one filled with water that is
99 degrees celsius, and the other is 1 degree celsius. The water that
is hot is colored red. The other one is colored blue. You have all
the tools you wish. Assume total conservation of energy. You would
like the red water to have temperature as low as you can get (ideally
1!), and the blue water to be as hot as you can get (ideally 99!).
How close can you get to the desired state?
#9 Defeats the second classical thermodynamics. Consider an ellipse.
If you have a piece of hot coal in each of the foci, all light given
out by these coals would be collected in the other foci (the property
of the ellipse). Let us now inscribe this ellipse in another ellipse,
of larger size, but with identical foci (in 3D, imagine an ellipsoid
enclosed in another ellipsoid). Now let's draw a circle of radius r
with center at one of the foci.
/-------\ /--\----\
/ _____ \ / \__ \
| / \ | | \ |
\ \_____/ / \ /__/ /
\---------/ \---/-----/
I'm sorry for this ugly drawing, but you get the idea. I simply
removed part of the inner ellipse. Now look what happens: ALL the
light coming from the focus at the right concentrates at the focus on
the left (where another piece of coal is located), but NOT ALL the
light from the left coal reaches the right coal, because part of it is
reflected by walls of the circle (sphere). We come to a paradox which
cannot be explained by classical thermodynamics: the heat balance is
not reached.
#10 You have two identical balloons, one sitting on a surface, the
other hanging from the ceiling. Equal forces act on each balloon. If
you supply the same amount of energy to each balloon (thus inflating
them), which will inflate more (if any), and why?
#11 The action takes place in the wild west. Bar. Sound of horse
hoofs, and a cowboy runs into the bar with a cry "Water!". The
barman, without much thinking, shoots into the ceiling. The cowboy
says "Thanks!" and exits the bar. Explain what happened and why.
Set 2 (Mike Lindesmith <mlinde@ix.netcom.com>, "some of my favs",
1996):
A deaf mute man walked over to the subway toll booth to pay. He
noticed that subway fare is 40 cents. He handed the cashier $1.00 and
the cashier handed the man 2 tickets and 20 cents change. The man made
no gestures for 2 tickets, so how did the cashier know he wanted 2
tickets?
A girl with blue eyes went out to view the skies. She saw an apple
tree with apples on it. She neither took apples nor left apples. How
many apples were on the tree?
If it takes a clock 6 seconds to strike 4:00pm, how long does it take
to strike 12:00pm?
Two children were selling cookies on a street corner. Each of them
started the day with 300 cookies. The boy sold his cookies two for 1
cent while the girl sold hers three for 1 cent. The second day, they
each started with the same 300 cookies but the girl talked the boy into
combining their cookies and selling them five for 2 cents. Thus, they
each would take their respective penny from each sale. Did anyone
benefit on the second day?
A woman has to take a trip down the road. She drives the first half
of the distance at 30 mph. How fast does she have to drive the second
half of the distance in order to average 60 mph for the entire trip?
You spend $10 every time you go to the gas station. The first time
you go, you notice gas costs $1 per gallon. It's easy to see that you
will get 10 gallons of gas. The next time you go, you notice gas costs
50 cents per gallon. Since this is half the cost, you get twice as
much or 20 gallons. The next time you go, you notice gas costs 75
cents per gallon which is midway between 50 cents and $1 but you don't
get 15 gallons which is midway between 10 and 20 gallons. Why not?
Mike has to flip a coin to determine who kicks off at a football game.
However, everyone knows that the coin is lopsided and it will land on
heads more often than tails. Mike uses the coin anyway and guarantees
a fair choosing. How?
Tina and Mike run a 100 yard race. Tina wins by ten yards. If they
race again at the same respective speeds, who wins if Tina starts 10
yards behind the starting line this time?
Two mercury droplets having exactly the same temperature combine into
one. Is the temperature of the new droplet any different from the
original two?
Sharon received two job offers. Company A offers starting salary of
$8000 with $300 raise every 6 months. Company B offers starting
salary of $8000 with $1200 raise every 12 months. Which pays better
and how much better?
Show solution
Set 1:
#1 Why, any male bird will do... how about a rooster?
#2 9, if you pulled out 8, you could have all 7 brown socks and only 1
white sock. or, if you looked, you could pull out 2.
#3 Assume the volume of jars are equal:
It will take 1 interval for jar 1 to produce 2 amoebae. It will
then fill up in 3hrs. So it takes 3 hours and 3 minutes.
#4 If we define "meet" where the heads of the trains collide and the
distance the train is from a city by the closest part of it, the
one coming from Moscow will be closer since its tail will be closer
to Moscow, and the one coming from St. Petersburg will be further
away by the length of the first train.
#5 I find it difficult to believe the ladder will be covered by water
if the boat was already floating, thus my first answer will be 10
meters. Although if I read the question to say: "the tide covers
10 centimeters [of the ladder] each hour" then the answer is
9.7meters remain (assuming that the ladder is vertical and the
water is relatively peaceful).
#6 Monday: Goes to 3m then falls to 2m.
Tuesday: Goes to 5m then falls to 4m.
Wednesday: Goes to 7m then falls to 6m.
Thursday: Goes to top of tree.
#7 Assume mass/volume density is the same for Coke (C) and Sprite (S)
After the first pouring, Then you'll have 100g Sprite + 1g Coke in
one glass and 99g Coke in the other. If coke dissolves uniformly
in sprite and vice-versa, then when you take a spoonfull of the
101g mixture, you'll get: 100/101g Sprite and 1/101g Coke in the
spoon. When you pour that into the 99g mixture, it will have
99+1/101g Coke and 100/101g Sprite.
So, we have 1g/101g * 100% = 0.9901% Coke in Sprite and,
(100/101g)/100g * 100% = 0.9901% Sprite in Coke.
#8 All the tools I want? How about a microwave? Or is it isolated at
this frequency too? Am I allowed to massively pressurize the jar?
Why not just add energy to it by moving it, stirring it... getting
those molecules in a random motion! Try vibrating it at a
frequency of 2.405GHz. Throw it against a wall a billion times
real fast! The possibilities are endless...
As for cooling it, how about expanding the jar, slowing down the
molecules by placing them under an intense, static magnetic field
to get those molecules pointing in the same direction--using
necessary energy to make sure that the field is truly static....a
little harder I suppose than refrigeration.
Oh wait, did you mean that we're to stick them in the ol'
calorimeter and hope that they come to the equilibrium
temperature? Hey, they're in ideally insulated jars--what good
would that do?
#9 Well, I don't think it seems that hard, unless there is an "answer"
you are looking for (or shall I say "for which you are looking?")
There are several factors to consider.
Assumptions:
1. The ellipsoid/spherical interface is perfectly reflecting.
2. We can retrieve all of the energy stored in the vacuum by
slowly collapsing the volume around each "coal" - taking care
not to favor one coal over another; so we can neglect the
energy "lost" by the fact that part of it is contained in the
volume.
3. For the assumption that the coal's radiation is initially
focused completely on the other ellipsoid is equivalent to
stating that all radiation from each coal is radiated normal to
the foci.
There are three cases:
1. Coal is an ideal insulator: the problem is trivial: all the
heat that is radiated from a differential surface area element
of the left coal that hits the circle will reflect back to the
same spot where it emitted. Thus there is no net change of
energy. The energy from those differential elements of the
left coal that do not hit the sphere will focus on exactly one
other differential element of the right coal (by assumption
#3); but since that other differential element is also
radiating energy directly at the aforementioned element of the
left sphere, we have a system of two differential elements
radiating at each other. The energy will distribute evenly
among the two elements. There is no net change of energy if
they started out with the same energy. One might complain that
the differential elements have unequal differential areas so
that the power radiated per unit area is different, but note
that it is the energy difference we are interested in which is
Power*Area--thus cancelling out the effect.
2. Coal is a perfect conductor: the energy radiated per unit area
of each coal is the same, since the surface of the coal is at
the same temperature. Since we assume the photons that carry
the energy are lossless, we have essentially a perfectly
conducting path from one coal to the other via means of the
ellipse.
3. Coal is intermediate between an insulator and conductor. The
solution to this approaches that of 2 as time progresses.
Since temperature is a time average phenomenon, we need not
worry about the time required to "redistribute" about the
surface in the unlikely event that they started off uneven.
#10 I'm getting sleepy so catch me on this if I mess up: The one that
is tied to the ceiling can contain more volume, because it is more
like a sphere than the other. the one resting on the surface will
deform the "spherical" surface of the balloon--causing it to
contain less volume. All of this hinges of course on my
(unsubstantiated) assumption that the surface area of the balloon
will remain nearly constant.
#11 The guy had the hiccoughs? ;)
-- Gregory E. Dionne <ged@lns61.tn.cornell.edu>
Set 2:
[Subway fare] He paid using three quarters. Had he only wanted one
ticket, he would have only given two of them.
[Apple tree] The standard answer is "two", under the logic that one
apple is "apple" not "apples", but that's stupid. If you had one
apple, and someone asked "how many apples do you have?", would you
answer "I don't have apples" or "one"?
[Clock] 22 seconds; there are 2 seconds between strikes. Does anyone
ever really get this one wrong?
[Cookies] Of course. Duh. The boy can sell his cookies for 1/2c
apiece while the girl sells her for 1/3c apiece. If the boy agrees to
the girl's proposal, he only gets 2/5c per cookie, a loss to him of
1/10c per cookie.
Simple arithmetic isn't really very puzzling, but for the record: the
first day, the boy made 150 sales for $1.50, while the girl made 100
sales for $1.00. The second day, they make 120 combined sales for
$2.40, which they split down the middle. The boy loses $0.30, while
the girl gains $0.20.
[Average speed] She can't.
[Gas] Uh, why should I?
75 cents is 3/4 of $1, which means you'll get 4/3 as much gas at 75
cents per gallon than $1 per gallon.
75 cents is 3/2 of 50 cents, which means you'll get 2/3 as much gas at
75 cents per gallon than 50 cents per gallon.
To check: at 75 cents per gallon, your $10.00 will buy 13 1/3 gallons,
which is 4/3 of 10 gallons, which is 2/3 of 20 gallons. No problem.
[Lopsided coin] There are several ways. One way is this: he flips it
twice. If it lands heads-tails, the home team kicks off. If it lands
tails-heads, the visitors kick off. If it shows the same face both
flips, he starts over.
[Race] Mike can run 90 yards in the time it takes Tina to run 100
yards, therefore, he can only run 99 yards in the time it takes her to
run 110 yards. Tina wins again.
[Mercury] This depends on *so* many external characteristics that the
question is meaningless.
[Salary] Both companies are in violation of the minimum wage, at least
at first.
The answer to the question is indeterminate and depends how long Sharon
remains with the companies. After one year, Company A would have paid
$8150 and company B would have paid $8000. After two years, Company A
would have paid $16,600 and company B would have paid $17,200. Company
B's advantage increases thereafter.
[ Editor: on the reckoning that gives $8150 for the first year (half
years at $8000, $8300, $8600, $8900 a year), Company A pays $4300 +
$4450 = $8750 in the second year, $16,900 in two years. ]
-- Jonathan S. Haas <positron@blarg.net>
[ Editor: the bracketed labels in set 2 are the editor's. ]
[ Editor: another version of the salary question, posted in 1998: ]
> Which would you choose :
>
> A starting salary of $ 1000 per yr with an increase of $ 200 each
> year
> or
>
> the same starting salary with an increase of $ 50 every six months ?
-- Judy & Irv <jidic2@webtv.net>
An even more surprising formulation, and one that avoids the quibbles
that you've gotten, would be:
which would you choose:
A starting salary of $12000 per year with an increase in yearly salary
of $1000 per year or
A starting salary of $1000 per month, with an increase in monthly
salary of $7 each month?
-- Jonathan Dushoff <dushoff@gate.sinica.edu.tw>
[ Editor: no answer to either version was found in the collected
postings. ]