How would you find out the height of a building using a barometer?
physics/barometer New
New entry, edited from material collected for the archive and not yet in a released version.
Problem
How would you find out the height of a building using a barometer? One day, a student was writing an exam in physics. The question was "Given a barometer, determine the height of a building." The student knew the *correct* answer, but she decided to be a lot more imaginative by giving other, correct answers. For example, she might have said, "I would drop the barometer from the top of the building, and time the fall with my digital stop watch. Using Newton's law of gravity, I could determine the height of the building." Using a bit (or a lot) of imagination, how else could we determine the height of the building? [ Editor: the first line as quoted by Mark Brader <msb@sq.com>; the rest posted by R Potvin <rpotvin@istar.ca>. ]
Show solution
Remember the question "How would you find out the height of a building using a barometer?" This was supposedly asked on a physics exam. The answer that a physics teacher probably intended is a poor one -- you can't read an ordinary barometer well enough to tell small changes in altitude. But people have produced *lots* of other answers. And I for one think this sort of thing is great fun. One or two of these are original with me as far as I know, by the way. Oddly enough, this one isn't in the archive. It does appear either in James Fixx's "Games for the Superintelligent" or in the followup "More Games for the Superintelligent"; about five answers are given there, as I recall. Here are nine solutions that don't involve reading the barometer. (Yes, air resistance will spoil most of them if [Editor: "of" in the original] the building is very tall. In that case the teacher's solution might be best after all.) 1. Drop the barometer off the roof or down a stairwell, and time the fall. 2. Drop the barometer off the roof or down a stairwell onto an impact- measuring device. (Weigh it first.) 3. The inverse of 2: build a catapult that ejects things with a calibrated, adjustable force. Fling the barometer from the catapult harder and harder until you know how much force will just get it to the roof. (Weighing it first. On this one, you'd better weigh what's left of it before *each* trial.) 4. Measure the length of the barometer, and walk up the stairs counting barometer-lengths along the wall. 5. Measure the length of the barometer and its shadow, and the shadow of the building. 6. Dangle the barometer from the roof or down a stairwell on a long cord, pull the cord back up, and measure its length. 7. Dangle the barometer from the roof or down a stairwell on a long cord, let it swing like a pendulum, and measure the swing period. 8. Find someone who knows the height of the building, and offer to give them the barometer in exchange for telling you the answer. 9. Find someone who knows the height of the building, and threaten to hit them with the barometer unless they tell you the answer. -- Mark Brader <msb@sq.com> You can tell the height of the building by comparing the shadows of the building and the barometer. If the barometer is placed at 90 degrees to the ground, assuming that is also the angle of the building to the ground. Each will cast a shadow that is in relation to the heights of the barometer and building. Measure the height of the barometer and its shadow and the shadow of the building. The height of the building then can be found. -- NHR <nhr@aol.com> This problem of measuring a building with a barometer is very old, and I believe I have seen around a dozen solutions. One of them was to use the barometer to measure the risers on the stairs all the way to the top. Another was to go to the building manager and say, "Here's a nice barometer you can have if you just tell me the height of the building." Etc. -- David Spero <mrrogers@igc.apc.org> I've seen a number of those answers before - let's see how many I can remember offhand. 1) The intended answer: Measure the relative humidity at the top and bottom of the building. Plug those numbers into some formula, which I don't know offhand. 2) Drop it from the roof and time its fall. 3) Lower it on a string from the roof till it touches the ground, then measure the length of the string. 4) Find someone who knows the height of the building and offer to give em the barometer if e will tell you. -- Ed Murphy <zvyezda@ix.netcom.com> [ Editor: a barometer measures air pressure, not humidity; the intended answer compares the air pressure at the top and the bottom of the building. ]